Cynar Julep

This Cynar julep is the cocktail to make when you want something bitter, bright, and a little unexpected. It's built with Cynar, fresh grapefruit juice, lemon, mint, and simple syrup over crushed ice, and it takes about five minutes to put together. If you're bored of sweet cocktails, this one is for you.

This post covers how to make a Cynar julep, a bittersweet cocktail made with Cynar, fresh grapefruit juice, lemon juice, simple syrup, and plenty of mint over crushed ice. It's written for anyone who likes low-ABV, bitter-leaning drinks like a Negroni or an Aperol spritz and wants something new to serve guests. You'll find the full recipe, an explanation of what Cynar actually tastes like, substitutions, garnish ideas, and a pitcher version that serves 8 to 10. What makes this version different is the mint syrup trick for big batches, which keeps the mint flavor from turning bitter and muddy when you scale the drink up for a crowd.

What is Cynar?

Cynar is an Italian amaro made from 13 herbs and plants, including artichoke. It's been made in Italy since 1952 and has an ABV of 16.5%, which is lower than most spirits and about the same as a glass of wine.

It does not taste like a plate of artichokes. It tastes bittersweet and herbal, with a caramel note underneath and a little vegetal edge on the finish. Think less sharp than Campari and less sugary than Aperol.

That low ABV is the reason this drink works so well for entertaining. You get a cocktail with real depth of flavor that your guests can sip on for an hour without needing a nap. If you like drinks built that way, the Americano is another good one to keep in your back pocket.

You'll love this Cynar julep

The balance of bitterness and sweetness is perfect. The grapefruit juice picks up the bitter side of the Cynar, the simple syrup rounds it out, and the lemon keeps everything sharp. Nothing gets lost.

It's easy to make. There's no shaking and no straining. You muddle, you add ice, you stir, and you're done.

It's a different cocktail to bring to the table, literally. Most people have not had a Cynar drink before. Serve this at a dinner party, and it will be the thing everyone asks about.

Cynar julep ingredients

Cynar. The star of the drink and the reason it tastes the way it does. Standard Cynar at 16.5% ABV is what you want here. There's also a bottle called Cynar 70 at 35% ABV, which is much stronger and will overpower the citrus in this recipe.

Grapefruit Juice. Fresh-squeezed makes a real difference. Bottled grapefruit juice tends to taste flat and slightly metallic, and since grapefruit is doing half the work in this drink, it's worth squeezing one. Pink or ruby-red grapefruit gives you sweeter, rounder juice than white grapefruit.

Lemon Juice. Just half an ounce, but it's what keeps the drink from tasting heavy. Fresh only.

Fresh Mint. Use the leaves for muddling and save a nice sprig for the top. Slap the garnish sprig between your hands before you add it so the oils wake up.

Simple Syrup. Equal parts sugar and hot water, stirred until dissolved. It keeps for a month in the fridge, so make a jar and stop thinking about it.

How to make a Cynar julep

1. Add the mint leaves, lemon juice, and simple syrup to a highball or julep cup. Press the mint gently with a muddler two or three times. You want to bruise it, not shred it.
2. Fill the glass with crushed ice and pour in the Cynar.
3. Swizzle or stir until the outside of the glass frosts over.
4. Top with the grapefruit juice, add more crushed ice to mound it over the rim, and garnish with a mint sprig.

Taste it before you serve it. Grapefruits vary a lot, so if yours was especially tart, add another quarter ounce of simple syrup.

Tips for the best Cynar julep

• Use crushed ice, not cubes. Crushed ice chills the drink fast and dilutes it just enough to soften the bitterness. If you don't have a crusher, put cubes in a clean kitchen towel and hit them with a rolling pin.
• Chill your glass first. A julep is supposed to frost. Stick the glass in the freezer for ten minutes while you juice the citrus.
• Go easy on the muddler. Overworked mint releases chlorophyll and tastes bitter and grassy, which fights with the Cynar instead of balancing it.
• My go-to move: I run a wide strip of grapefruit peel around the rim before dropping it in the glass. It adds a hit of citrus oil right where your nose goes, and it makes the first sip taste brighter than it actually is.

Substitutions and variations for a Cynar julep

Grapefruit Soda. Swap the fresh juice for a chilled grapefruit soda, such as Sanpellegrino Pompelmo or Squirt. You'll get a fizzy, slightly sweeter version, and you can skip the simple syrup entirely. This is the closest thing to how Cynar is often served in Argentina.

Honey Syrup. Use honey syrup in place of simple syrup for a rounder, warmer drink. Mix two parts honey with one part hot water so it pours easily. This is my pick once the weather turns cold.

Add a spirit. An ounce of bourbon, rye, or cachaça gives the drink more backbone and takes it closer to a classic julep. Bourbon plays nicest with the caramel notes in the Cynar.

Swap the amaro. No Cynar on hand? Averna is the closest match. Amaro Montenegro works too and gives you a lighter, more orange-forward drink.

Make it a mocktail. Combine grapefruit juice, lemon, mint, simple syrup, and a splash of strong brewed black tea over crushed ice. The tea brings back some of the tannic bitterness you lose when you omit the amaro.

Cynar julep garnish ideas

• A big mint bouquet, slapped once to release the oils
• A wide strip of grapefruit peel
• A thin grapefruit half moon on the rim
• A dusting of powdered sugar over the mint for a classic julep look

How to make a big batch of this Cynar julep

This drink scales beautifully for a party, with one adjustment. Do not muddle mint into a pitcher. It sits in the liquid, turns bitter, and clouds the whole batch. Make a quick mint syrup instead.

For the mint syrup: heat 1 cup sugar and 1 cup water until the sugar dissolves, pull it off the heat, add a packed cup of mint leaves, and let it steep for 20 minutes. Strain and chill. This makes enough for the batch with extra left over.

For 8 servings, combine in a pitcher:

• 16 oz Cynar
• 4 oz fresh lemon juice
• 4 oz mint syrup

Stir and refrigerate. You can do this up to two days ahead.

When guests arrive, fill glasses with crushed ice, pour about 3 oz of the pitcher mix into each glass, and top with 2 oz of fresh grapefruit juice. Add the grapefruit at the last minute so it stays bright, then garnish each glass with mint.

If you'd rather not pour drinks all night, set the pitcher and a carafe of grapefruit juice next to a bucket of crushed ice and a bowl of mint and let people build their own.

Cynar julep FAQs

What is a Cynar julep?

A Cynar julep is a bittersweet cocktail made with Cynar, an Italian artichoke amaro, plus grapefruit juice, lemon, simple syrup, and mint served over crushed ice. It's a lower-ABV riff on the classic mint julep, and a popular way to drink Cynar in Argentina.

What does Cynar taste like?

Cynar tastes bittersweet and herbal, with caramel and toffee notes and a slightly vegetal finish. It does not taste like artichokes, even though artichoke is one of its 13 botanicals. It's less bitter than Campari and less sweet than Aperol.

Is Cynar strong?

No. Cynar is 16.5% ABV, which is about the same as a glass of wine and much lower than most spirits. That makes it a good choice for daytime drinking and long parties. The separate Cynar 70 bottling is 35% ABV.

What mixes well with Cynar?

Grapefruit, citrus, mint, tonic, soda water, prosecco, and cola all mix well with Cynar. Bitter and slightly sweet mixers balance its herbal edge. It also works as a swap for Campari in a Negroni or a Boulevardier.

Does Cynar need to be refrigerated?

No. Cynar is shelf-stable and keeps for months in a cool, dark cabinet after opening. Refrigerating it is optional, though many people like it chilled since it's often served over ice.

Can I use bottled grapefruit juice?

You can, but fresh is noticeably better. Bottled grapefruit juice loses its brightness and can taste slightly bitter, which fights the Cynar. If you're using bottled, taste and add a little extra simple syrup.

What's a good Cynar substitute?

Averna is the closest substitute for Cynar in this recipe, followed by Amaro Montenegro or Amaro Nonino. All three are bittersweet Italian amari, though each shifts the drink slightly sweeter or more citrus-forward.

Pin it for later!

Want more cocktail recipes?

• The Perfect Fall Aperol Spritz
• Hugo Spritz Recipe
• Lillet Spritz Recipe
• Aperol Cocktails Perfect for Summer