This browned butter apple cider old fashioned is the coziest bourbon cocktail I make all fall. It's just three ingredients: browned butter-infused bourbon, fresh apple cider, and bitters. It tastes like a warm apple crisp with a scoop of buttery caramel on top, and it's easy enough to stir up one at a time or batch for your whole Thanksgiving table.
AT A GLANCE
A browned butter apple cider Old Fashioned is a fall twist on the classic Old Fashioned made with browned butter-infused bourbon, apple cider, and aromatic bitters. The browned butter gives the bourbon a nutty, toffee-like flavor and silky texture, while the apple cider adds natural sweetness, so you don't need simple syrup or a sugar cube. This recipe is for home hosts who want an easy, make-ahead Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving cocktail that feels special. It includes a single-cocktail method, a big-batch version for 10, the best bourbon and cider to use, substitutions, and garnish ideas.
This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission when you click on the links and make a purchase. I will never recommend a product that I don't support 100%.
You'll love this Browned Butter Apple Cider Old Fashioned
It tastes like apple pie in a rocks glass. The browned-butter bourbon brings caramel and toasted-nut flavor, and the cider brings fresh, tart apple. Together they taste like dessert, without being sweet.
It's only three ingredients. Bourbon, cider, and bitters. There's no syrup to cook and no muddling. Once you've made your browned butter bourbon, each drink takes about a minute.
It's a crowd pleaser for Thanksgiving. It's familiar enough for the old-fashioned fans at the table and soft enough for guests who don't usually drink bourbon. It's one of my favorite drinks in this year's Drinksgiving lineup for exactly that reason.
Ingredients
Browned Butter-Infused Bourbon. This bourbon is steeped with browned butter, then frozen and strained so the flavor stays and the fat doesn't. It makes the bourbon taste smoother and richer, with notes of toffee and butter cookies. You'll need to make it at least 6 hours ahead, and my browned butter-infused bourbon post walks you through every step. Buffalo Trace or Maker's Mark are both great bourbons to start with.
Apple Cider. Use fresh, unfiltered apple cider, the cloudy kind you find in the refrigerated section or at the farmers market in the fall. It has more true apple flavor and a little tartness, which balances the rich bourbon. Skip clear apple juice, which tastes flat and too sweet here. Hard cider is a different drink, so save that for a spritz.
Bitters. Bitters are the seasoning of an Old Fashioned. They add warm spice and keep the drink from tasting one-note. Angostura aromatic bitters are the classic choice and what I use most. If you have orange bitters on hand, swapping one dash for orange is really nice with apple.
How to make a Browned Butter Apple Cider Old Fashioned
This makes one cocktail. Make your browned butter bourbon ahead of time.
- Add 2 oz browned butter bourbon, 1 oz apple cider, and 2 to 3 dashes of bitters to a mixing glass.
- Fill the mixing glass about three-quarters full with ice.
- Stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the outside of the glass feels very cold.
- Strain into a rocks glass over one large ice cube.
- Garnish and serve.
Why I did it this way: a classic Old Fashioned uses a sugar cube or simple syrup for sweetness. Here, the apple cider does that job. One ounce adds just enough sweetness and apple flavor while keeping the drink spirit-forward like a true Old Fashioned. Any more cider and it starts to taste like spiked cider instead.
Why stir instead of shake? Old Fashioneds are stirred so they stay silky and clear. Shaking adds air bubbles and too much water, which would hide all that buttery texture you worked to build.
Substitutions and variations
Use rye instead of bourbon. Browned butter rye is a little spicier and drier. It's great if you like a less sweet Old Fashioned.
Skip the browned butter. Short on time? Use your favorite regular bourbon. It won't have the toasty, buttery flavor, but it's still a delicious apple cider Old Fashioned.
Add maple. Add ¼ oz pure maple syrup if you like your Old Fashioned sweeter. Maple and browned butter taste like a pancake breakfast in the best way.
Make it cinnamon-spiced. Add ¼ oz cinnamon syrup, or let a cinnamon stick sit in the drink as you sip. It leans even more into apple pie.
Try different bitters. Black walnut bitters taste nutty and are great with browned butter. Apple or chai bitters also work well. Use 2 dashes of Angostura plus 1 dash of the fun one.
Use mulled cider. If you have a pot of mulled cider going for a party, use 1 oz of it (cooled) in place of plain cider for extra spice.
Garnish ideas
- A thin apple slice or apple fan
- A cinnamon stick
- A wide orange peel, expressed over the drink
- A dehydrated apple chip on the rim
- A pinch of flaky sea salt on the ice cube
- A Luxardo cherry
- A star anise pod floating on top

How to make a big batch of this Browned Butter Apple Cider Old Fashioned
This big-batch version makes 10 cocktails, and you can mix it a full day ahead. That's the beauty of an Old Fashioned. No citrus goes dull, so it's one of the best make-ahead Thanksgiving cocktails.
Big batch for 10:
- 2 ½ cups browned butter bourbon
- 1 ¼ cups apple cider
- 1 tablespoon Angostura bitters (about 20 to 25 dashes)
- ¾ cup cold water
For 2 ½ cups of browned butter bourbon, make the full-bottle version (a 750 ml bottle with 1 ½ sticks of butter). You'll have a little extra for a nightcap.
Stir the browned butter bourbon, apple cider, bitters, and water in a pitcher or large bottle. Cover and chill in the fridge for up to 24 hours. Fresh cider tastes best within a day, so I wait until the night before to mix it.
Why add water? When you stir a cocktail with ice, some of that ice melts into the drink. That dilution is what makes an Old Fashioned smooth instead of harsh. Adding water to the batch does the same job, so you can pour straight from the fridge.
To serve, stir and pour about 3 ½ oz into each rocks glass over a large ice cube. I like to set out a tray of glasses with the ice already in them, plus a little bowl of apple slices and cinnamon sticks so everyone can garnish their own.
FAQs
Can you put apple cider in an Old Fashioned?
Yes, apple cider is a great addition to an Old Fashioned. It replaces the sugar cube or simple syrup, adding natural sweetness and fresh apple flavor. Use about 1 oz of cider for every 2 oz of bourbon to keep the drink spirit-forward.
What does a brown butter Old Fashioned taste like?
A brown butter Old Fashioned tastes nutty, toasty, and a little like caramel or toffee. It feels smoother and silkier than a regular Old Fashioned. It doesn't taste greasy because the butter is frozen and strained out of the bourbon.
What is the best bourbon for an apple cider Old Fashioned?
The best bourbon for an apple cider Old Fashioned is a mid-priced bottle around 90 to 100 proof, like Buffalo Trace, Wild Turkey 101, or Maker's Mark. Wheated bourbons like Maker's Mark taste especially soft and smooth with browned butter and apple.
Is an Old Fashioned shaken or stirred?
An Old Fashioned is always stirred. Stirring chills and dilutes the drink while keeping it silky and clear. Even with apple cider added, stirring is the way to go here.
Can you make an apple cider Old Fashioned ahead of time?
Yes, you can make an apple cider Old Fashioned up to 24 hours ahead. Mix the bourbon, cider, bitters, and water in a pitcher and keep it in the fridge. Pour over ice and garnish right before serving.
Pin it for later!
Want more Thanksgiving cocktails?
- Apple Cider Martini
- Spiced Cider Spritz
- Caramel Apple Martini
- Salted Caramel Martini
- Chocolate Old Fashioned
- The Harvest Crisp Martini
- Make-Ahead Thanksgiving Negroni Royale
- Spiced Pear Sidecar
Browned Butter Apple Cider Old Fashioned
This browned butter apple cider old fashioned is the coziest bourbon cocktail I make all fall. It's just three ingredients: browned butter-infused bourbon, fresh apple cider, and bitters. It tastes like a warm apple crisp with a scoop of buttery caramel on top, and it's easy enough to stir up one at a time or batch for your whole Thanksgiving table.
Ingredients
- 2 oz browned butter bourbon
- 1 oz apple cider
- 2-3 dashes bitters
Instructions
- Add 2 oz browned butter bourbon, 1 oz apple cider, and 2 to 3 dashes of bitters to a mixing glass.
- Fill the mixing glass about three-quarters full with ice.
- Stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the outside of the glass feels very cold.
- Strain into a rocks glass over one large ice cube.
- Garnish and serve.
Why I did it this way: a classic Old Fashioned uses a sugar cube or simple syrup for sweetness. Here, the apple cider does that job. One ounce adds just enough sweetness and apple flavor while keeping the drink spirit-forward like a true Old Fashioned. Any more cider and it starts to taste like spiked cider instead.
Why stir instead of shake? Old Fashioneds are stirred so they stay silky and clear. Shaking adds air bubbles and too much water, which would hide all that buttery texture you worked to build.
Notes
Substitutions and variations
Use rye instead of bourbon. Browned butter rye is a little spicier and drier. It's great if you like a less sweet Old Fashioned.
Skip the browned butter. Short on time? Use your favorite regular bourbon. It won't have the toasty, buttery flavor, but it's still a delicious apple cider Old Fashioned.
Add maple. Add ¼ oz pure maple syrup if you like your Old Fashioned sweeter. Maple and browned butter taste like a pancake breakfast in the best way.
Make it cinnamon-spiced. Add ¼ oz cinnamon syrup, or let a cinnamon stick sit in the drink as you sip. It leans even more into apple pie.
Try different bitters. Black walnut bitters taste nutty and great with browned butter. Apple or chai bitters also work well. Use 2 dashes of Angostura plus 1 dash of the fun one.
Use mulled cider. If you have a pot of mulled cider going for a party, use 1 oz of it (cooled) in place of plain cider for extra spice.
Garnish ideas
- A thin apple slice or apple fan
- A cinnamon stick
- A wide orange peel, expressed over the drink
- A dehydrated apple chip on the rim
- A pinch of flaky sea salt on the ice cube
- A Luxardo cherry
- A star anise pod floating on top
My go-to is a thin apple slice tucked against the ice and a cinnamon stick. It looks beautiful on a Thanksgiving table and tells guests what's in the glass before they even take a sip. For a salted caramel taste, add a tiny pinch of flaky salt on top of the ice cube.
How to make a big batch of this Browned Butter Apple Cider Old Fashioned
The big batch version makes 10 cocktails, and you can mix it a full day ahead. That's the beauty of an Old Fashioned. No citrus goes dull, so it's one of the best make-ahead Thanksgiving cocktails.
Big batch for 10:
- 2 ½ cups browned butter bourbon
- 1 ¼ cups apple cider
- 1 tablespoon Angostura bitters (about 20 to 25 dashes)
- ¾ cup cold water
For 2 ½ cups of browned butter bourbon, make the full-bottle version (a 750 ml bottle with 1 ½ sticks of butter). You'll have a little extra for a nightcap.
Stir the browned butter bourbon, apple cider, bitters, and water in a pitcher or large bottle. Cover and chill in the fridge for up to 24 hours. Fresh cider tastes best within a day, so I wait until the night before to mix it.
Why add water? When you stir a cocktail with ice, some of that ice melts into the drink. That dilution is what makes an Old Fashioned smooth instead of harsh. Adding water to the batch does the same job, so you can pour straight from the fridge.
To serve, give it a stir and pour about 4 ½ oz into each rocks glass over a large ice cube. I like to set out a tray of glasses with the ice already in them, plus a little bowl of apple slices and cinnamon sticks so everyone can garnish their own.